An Answer To Detractors

Over the last week or so I’ve had several people send me links to blogs that have been talking about The Campaign For Really Good Beer.
Just over half of them have been knocking CAMRGB in one way or another.
Or they’ve at least been doing a Derrida and disassembling it to find out what it means.

Initially I told myself I wouldn’t get involved in the debate.
I’d just let people say what they want to and carry on regardless.
But last night I thought about all the things people have been saying and it suddenly struck me how obvious it was what CAMRGB is really all about, and how I can sum it up in one simple (though probably convoluted as I like a bit of a rant) metaphor.

Many bloggers have said they can’t see exactly what CAMRGB is all about, that it’s a bit glib, faux naive, and that a movement needs to take sides.

My answer.
If honesty and straightforward talking comes across as naive (however faux it might be) then so be it.
Yes, I may come across as a bit glib, we all have our faults.
As for which side are we one, well, I think it’s absolutely obvious which side we’re on.
We’re on the side of people who love to drink beer and experiment and take chances and…here comes the metaphor (or is it a simili)…

I approach the way I buy beer in exactly the same way that I used to buy records.
I’m constantly looking for something new to try, to discover, to excite me.

It appears, from what’s been happening over the last few weeks since CAMRGB began is that there are two distinct camps of people – They all love great beer, but they have distinctly different ways of expressing it.
And those ways again are part of my extended music metaphor.

My father was a classically trained musician and he had to take everything apart to explain why something was good.
If he heard me playing a new 7″ over and over and over he’d ask why I liked it so much.
He would say, “but it’s not in tune and it speeds up and slows down and there’s no musicianship.”
And I would reply, “But it FEELS GOOD!

And therein lies the crux of CAMRGB.

There are people who want, like Prog Rock fans of yore (and don’t get me wrong I love Hatfield and The North and Genesis and Henry Cow), to “understand” why something is good.
They seem to need to quantify everything by taking it apart and then being able to lecture on how they know that this thing is good  because they have spent a long time studying it and its constituent parts are x, y and z.

Then there are people who, like the record buyers I was part of in the late 70’s and through the 80’s, would put all their energy into discovering, and when they found something that made their heart race and their hair stand on end and made them smile for a week and want to listen over and over and over out of pure joy felt the overwhelming need to SHARE.
To tell someone, anyone, everyone else about what they’d just discovered.

As we get older those moments of pure unadulterated joy get less and less.
Musically we turn into our parents and start talking about how music used to be.
Yes we buy and enjoy new things, but that immense feeling of sheer jubilation isn’t there.

The one and only place I come close to that feeling is when I go into an independent beer shop or into a good pub and look at the beers from all over the world, from tiny little breweries, from people who work with passion.

I do the same as I used to do in record shops – I talk to the owner, I pick up and put down bottles, studying the labels for hints of why this one should be the one I try today.
And then if the one I choose is amazing I want everyone to know about it so they can try it too.
They may not enjoy it as much as I did, but at least I’ll have shared my passion.

That ladies and gentlemen, is what The Campaign For Really Good Beer is all about, and if you think me naive and if you think me glib I couldn’t care less.

Join the forum discussion on this post

About Simon Williams

Founder of CAMRGB. Member of The British Guild Of Beer Writers. Leftist bigmouth. Old and grumpy.
This entry was posted in Beer Events, Beer Review, Beer Shop, Beer Travels, CAMRA, CAMRGB, Interview. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to An Answer To Detractors

  1. Pingback: We Should Get Excited: Beavertown Brewery Neck Oil (4.3%) & Partizan Brewing Stout (8.6%) | CAMRGB

  2. Pingback: I Found That Essence Rare: Brewing’s Newest Wave | CAMRGB

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.